Doctor Who BF-161 The Butcher of Brisbane

"Adopting the alias of Weng-Chiang, the 51st century war criminal Magnus Greel will one day arrive in Victorian London by Time Cabinet – only to meet his doom, his plans undone by the Time Lord known as the Doctor."

It feels like I've been waiting for this story forever. Not only is it more of my currently favourite TARDIS crew, but it's also the return of Magnus Greel, who hasn't been seen since another favourite of mine "The Talons of Weing-Chiang."

I like the idea that this is actually a prequel and a sequel to TTWC. But I can't remember if Magnus recognised the Doctor by name in the televised adventure. I'll have to rewatch the story again.

I really liked the idea of Nyssa pretending to love Magnus so she could find out what he was really up to. Creating sympathy for the character I've thought of as "A really evil being" for years, is a difficult task. And Big Finish did it incredibly well.

I had a very vivid image in my head of Mr Sin chasing people round with a knife, and I found it hilarious, even though I'm sure it was meant to be a serious scene. I guess there's no way for me to escape the low production values of classic who.

All the cast made brilliant performances, I knew that I recognised Magnus' voice, and it turned out that he portrayed Mister Dred in a Sarah Jane Adventures episode. As soon as I realised, all I could imagine was Magnus walking round wearing a suit and sunglasses.

I liked the idea of both groups having an intelligent person with them. Turlough and Nyssa went one way, and the Doctor and Tegan went the other. I still haven't warmed up to Nyssa, though. Maybe it's because two intelligent minds in the TARDIS isn't as fun? I don't know.

In conclusion, this is a fantastic story, and didn't let me down in the slightest. Brilliant mental imagery is created throughout. And it's always good to see the Fifth Doctor and Tegan bicker. Even if Miss Jovanka has always secretly annoyed me...

8/10

Doctor Who BF-025 Colditz

"As World War Two draws towards its conclusion, a Nazi defeat begins to seem almost inevitable. But that might be about to change..."
Colditz is a great story. I am a huge fan of Nazi stories, as I’ve studied the Nazis from a young age, because I have always been fascinated by them. So as you’ve probably guessed, I love it when they are in Doctor Who. I think the thing I like most about Nazi stories is the fact that the Doctor has complete opposite views to them. And the contrast is enjoyable.

Similar to my review of “Eye of the Scorpion”, I’m going to get this part out of the way. But Ace… Is really hot. She’s awesome, strong willed, and attractive. Everything a companion of the Doctors should be. But I’ll admit, I never in my life time thought I’d hear David Tennant tell Ace to “Take off [her] clothes and put them in the bag.” Ok, the fan boy moment is over.

David Tennants performance was brilliant. I didn’t actually know it was David Tennant until episode two, where he turns a little bit too Scottish for a Nazi. The ending made me feel terribly sorry for Davids character, Kurtz. No one deserves to have the same fate he had.

Klein is also a fantastic character. After listening to “Colditz” I jumped ahead to “A thousand Tiny Wings”, “Survival of the fittest” and “The Architects of History” to hear the conclusion to this story. I’ll try not to give too much away, because I’ll review these three stories later. But let’s just say- I wasn’t disappointed.

My favourite moment from this episode is the ending, when Ace decides that after the events she witnessed at Colditz, that she will now be known as Dorothy Shane. This makes me want to listen to the next story in the Seventh Doctor and Ace big finish line (The Rapture) Which I hope I’ll enjoy.

In conclusion, this story may be a brilliant start to a change in dynamic of the seventh doctor and Ace. Only time will tell!

9/10

Doctor Who BF-105 The Condemned

"Manchester, 2008. The TARDIS lands inside a run-down tower block, beside a dead body – which leads to some awkward questions when the Doctor is found there by the police. Made the prime suspect, how can the Doctor prove to the no-nonsense DI Patricia Menzies that this is not the open-and-shut case it seems, and that she’s actually investigating the death of an alien?"

The Condemned is my favourite sixth doctor story, and my favourite big finish story so far. The images created in this story are fantastic. I have listened to this story at least ten times over the past year, because it is still full of surprises.

Detective Inspector Patricia Menzies (Anna Hope) is brilliant. If the Jago and Litefoot series ever finishes, I would encourage Big Finish to give her a spin off. “DI Menzies- protecting the streets of Manchester from alien life.” It could happen, and I would preorder the series now, if I could. Even without a synopsis.

You may have noticed that I mentioned DI Menzies before Charley Pollard (India Fisher) but don’t take that as a suggestion that I’m not a Charely fan. I am quite a big Charley fan, as a matter of fact. I have only listened to one or two eighth doctor and charley episodes, but as soon as I listened to “The Condemned”, I quickly ran through all of the sixth doctor and Charley episodes, whilst in France. I am still not clear how the “Charley hasn’t met the Doctor yet” plotline, so I’ll have to take another listen to them before I write a review.

At first, I thought that I’d be disappointed by the Doctors blue coat, because it didn’t seem to fit. But by the time episode one had finished, I just knew that it worked. The blue coat matches the Doctors changed attitude. In the television series, he was arrogant, rude, and harsh. But like a good wine, the Sixth Doctor has mellowed with age.

Listening to this after listening to the big finish audio “The Crimes of Thomas Brewster”, I see how carefully (if not accidently) this story has been carved. It was revealed in TCOTB that the events in “The Condemned” was not the first meeting between the Doctor and DI Menzies. And upon their “supposingly ” first meeting, the Doctor mutters “Typical…” When DI Menzies bursts onto the scene.

So, in conclusion, “The Condemned” is a great story, and is a fantastic start for any listeners new to big finish. A PERFECT big finish story. This is how the sixth Doctor needs to be written.

10/10